So maybe you’ve followed along with my appraisal series, maybe you’re in a transaction, maybe you’re contemplating what might happen in a transaction and you’re thinking, but Cindy, we don’t want to put an extra $10,000, $20,000 in a house if it didn’t appraise. What do we do now?
Well, obviously, nobody wants to feel like they’re overpaying and I think overpaying is a real relative term when we are in the market that we’ve been in for the last few years really. Overpaying really is a nebulous idea. If 10 people want the house and the house was listed at $410k, and it gets bid up to $450k, and there were multiple offers. You competed against nine other people, you got the house at $450k. Good for you. You won. But now the appraisal comes in at $425k and you don’t know what to do. You don’t have an extra $25,000 to get you there. So there are a few options. And I’ve talked about some in other videos. But what if you want to dispute the appraisal? What if you feel like hey, this is not right. I feel like this house is really worth $450k and I want to make sure that my deal doesn’t fall apart because we love this house. Or maybe you’re the seller and you say listen, I had 10 people want to buy my house, and fair and square, we got bid up to $450k. Now some person is coming in and telling me and the buyers that it’s only worth $425k. You’re really throwing a wrench in my plans. What do you do in those cases?
Well, you can dispute an appraisal, but it is a process. Because the lenders really want to make sure that it’s an unbiased sort of set of data and an unbiased opinion of value, they’re not real keen on the agents, whether listing or buyer’s agents, or the buyers and sellers getting real involved in that process and trying to manipulate that data. Because again, unbiased means they’re looking at data, and the data is the data. But I have had situations where we were successfully able to dispute the appraisal. It doesn’t happen often though. You really have to have, again, data to go back to the appraiser and say, here is a comparable that you did not use. Why didn’t you use this comparable? It almost never works, because these people do their job and the appraisal has to be reviewed by someone else in their office as well. It’s not a one person saying check, yes, this house has, you know, everything that it takes to be a $450,000 house. It really has to have all of the supporting information and it gets reviewed a number of times before that stamp goes on to say this is complete. So if you do have comparables that show something or when you look at the appraisal, they have missed something that is an integral part of your house, it’s got a brand new roof, but they noted that the roof was old because maybe they made a mistake or you know, they’re human. So maybe somebody didn’t have all their coffee that day and thought the roof looked old. There is a process, through which it’s a little different with every lender, you can dispute the appraisal, but just remember that odds are it’s not usually going to go in your favor. So you may need to look at some of the other options to work that appraisal out.
If you have any questions about the appraisal process or the appraisal dispute process, drop them in the comments or reach out to me. I’d love to help you. Figure out how you might deal with such an occurrence. But if you’re currently in a transaction, I’m going to say reach out to your lender, your agent or your attorney and figure out how to best deal with that situation.