Main Content

What if There is an Issue with Your Home Appraisal?

So what do you do if there is an issue with the appraisal?

Let’s give an example. You purchase a house for $450,000 and the appraisal comes back and it’s $425k. Now, what do you do?

Well, in our contract, and again, this is the Central Virginia contract. So I’m in the Richmond area, surrounding counties, we have our own particular contract, the contract where you are may be different. In our contract, it states that within five days of receiving that appraisal, the purchaser has the right to request in writing, whatever sort of resolution they would like from the seller and that can be a number of different things.

First off, they can request that the price be reduced. So if the house is $450,000, that’s what the contract price is, the appraisal comes in for $425k. Maybe you’re the purchaser and you don’t have an extra $25,000. You may have to go to the seller in writing and say, ‘Can you please reduce the price to $425k’. Now they can say yes, or they can say no, or they can present a different option. But if you cannot come to a resolution, then all parties can walk away. No harm, no foul.

Another resolution might be that, say you were in a competitive situation when you wrote the offer and you wrote the offer for $450k. There were a number of other offers, you do have the cash to back it up, and you say, oh rats the home appraisal came in at $425k, but we really want the house. We feel like it’s worth $450k. It’s worth 450 to us and we’re willing to throw an extra $25,000 in there to bridge that gap. Obviously, you need to have 25,000 extra dollars. Or in some cases, you can kind of maneuver your loan a little bit to come up with a little extra cash, but that’s between you and your lender. So the buyer can actually pay the cash difference, the lender doesn’t care. What the lender cares about is if they’re giving you 80% of the value, they’re only going to give you 80% of the value that the appraiser says it’s worth, period, end of story. They’re not going to give you any extra because you really liked the house because it was a competitive situation. They don’t care because it’s the bottom line number for the lender and that is ultimately who the appraiser works for.